The Repeal of the Natural Health Product Regulations

Discussion Paper Release - April 2018

Discussion Paper by Shawn Buckley

Published October 2017, last updated May 2019

Because the opposition to Bill C-51 in 2008 was so strong, Health Canada devised a new way to get the severe penalties and powers to apply to natural products. They came out with Bill C-17 which brought in the powers and penalties for a new category of “therapeutic product”. Therapeutic product was defined to exclude natural health products as that term is defined in the Natural Health Products Regulations. Because natural health products were excluded, the public did not raise a fuss and Bill C-17 passed. The NHPPA had called Bill C-17 a Trojan Horse.

The danger of the change brought about by Bill C-17 is that Health Canada can make the powers and penalties that were in Bill C-51 applicable to natural products by simply amending the Natural Health Product Regulations (which they have since done in 2023).

Action Needed Now

Please educate yourself about what Health Canada has set into motion by downloading and reading the Discussion Paper to find out exactly how the regulation changes will affect you.

Excerpts From The Discussion Paper

  • “Claims will be restricted to minor conditions – conditions for which a person would not seek the advice of a health care practitioner licensed by a province such as a naturopathic doctor, a traditional Chinese medicine doctor, an Ayurvedic doctor, a nutritionist, a herbalist, etc. Anyone who thinks professional natural products will be around in 2 years is naive;”

  • “Health Canada and the Auditor General do know that you are more likely to be struck by lightning than to die from a NHP. They know there is no meaningful risk from NHPs that require any government action. What the Health Canada and Auditor General messaging means is that both agencies are willing to mislead you to achieve an agenda not connected to health.”

  • “Natural products will not qualify as self-care products if meant for any health condition that will require the intervention of a health professional. If they do not qualify under the self-care product regulations, the only drug regulations they could be licensed under are the prescription drug regulations, which natural products generally cannot comply with. This would take us back to before the Natural Health Product Regulations when virtually all natural products were illegal. Only now it will be professional products manufactured to treat conditions requiring a doctor (be it medical, naturopathic, homeopathic or traditional like TCM practitioners) that will be illegal.”

  • “There is also an invitation to comment. However, the Notice makes it clear that fees will be imposed, regardless of comments. This is found as follows: The fee proposal is subject to a 75-day consultation period. The feedback received will be used to refine the proposal as the Department seeks to implement fees that reflect the NHP program in a fair and transparent way. The fee proposal will then be finalized, and a fee order will be published in the Canada Gazette, Part II. Fees are planned to come into force on April 1, 2025. The fee proposal will be posted for 75 calendar days, ending July 26, 2025.”

  • “Many Canadians are only alive because of natural health products. Many more solve or manage serious health conditions with them. We cannot pretend that taking away treatments people rely upon for their lives and/or well-being will not lead to death or suffering.”